· AI

Your AI Readiness Assessment Should End With a Number You Can Check Later

A readiness assessment that ends in a maturity score instead of a number you can check later is not diligence. It is a nicer-looking guess.

ISACA asked more than 3,400 digital trust professionals about AI return on investment for its 2026 AI Pulse Poll, and the answers split four ways: 22 percent say ROI has met or exceeded expectations, 20 percent say it has been limited, 22 percent say they do not know, and 23 percent say it is too early to tell. Add the last three together and 65 percent of organizations, most of them well past their first AI pilot, cannot currently say whether the money paid off. Keith Bloomfield-DeWeese, ISACA's senior manager of AI product development, put it plainly in the release: "the thing with ROI in AI is that it doesn't arrive on schedule; it's not a switch that can be flipped."

That line is true and also lets everyone off the hook. My position: the honest reason two-thirds of companies cannot answer the ROI question is not that AI returns are slow to show up. It is that almost nobody wrote down, before they spent the money, what number would count as the answer.

The case for the maturity score anyway

There is a real argument for the standard readiness assessment, the one that scores your data quality, your governance, and your team on a scale and hands you a roadmap. For a company that has never used AI for anything, that score is genuinely useful. It tells you your customer records live in four disconnected systems before you find that out the expensive way, mid-project. A structured look at data, process, and governance maturity catches the kind of foundational gap that kills an AI build regardless of which model you pick, and a business with no internal AI expertise has no better way to see that gap than paying someone whose job is to look for it.

Why the score still leaves you exactly where ISACA found you

Here is where that falls short. A maturity score answers "are we ready to start." It does not answer "how will we know if this worked," and that second question is the one 65 percent of organizations in ISACA's data cannot currently answer. You can score a nine out of ten on governance maturity and still have no defined success metric for the specific AI project you greenlit, because readiness and accountability are different questions, and most assessments only ask the first one. The 23 percent who call their ROI "too early to tell" are the clearest version of this. Generative AI tools have been commercially available for enterprise use for three years now. "Too early to tell" at this point usually does not mean the project just started. It means nobody defined, at the start, what finish line they were measuring against, so there is nothing to check the calendar against now.

The fix costs nothing extra and does not require a bigger engagement. Before you pay for or run any readiness work, write one sentence: "this project succeeds if X moves from A to B by this date." A support deflection rate. A quote turnaround time. A dollar figure in hours saved, measured against a baseline you took before you started, not estimated after. That sentence is not hard to write. It is just uncomfortable, because it is the sentence that will prove you wrong if the project does not work, and a maturity score never puts anyone in that position. A report that scores your governance a 7 out of 10 flatters everyone in the room. A number with a date on it does not.

What to actually ask for

If you are evaluating a readiness assessment, do not just ask what it scores. Ask whether the deliverable includes a specific, measurable success metric for your first use case, tied to a number you already have today, with a date to check it. If the proposal stops at a maturity score and a roadmap, you are buying half the product. The other half, holding the project to a number instead of a vibe, is the part that actually tells you if AI paid off, and it is the part AI advisory work should insist on writing down before the first dollar gets spent, not after the ROI question comes up at the next board meeting. If your last assessment ended in a score and nothing you can check against today, that is worth a conversation. Start one at mojoaiservices.com/#contact.

Sources

References used in this article. Links also appear alongside the relevant claims.

Let's talk

Let's make it happen.

You don't need a polished brief. A couple of lines about where you want your company to go is plenty, and we'll come back with what we'd tackle first.

We scope the work around your goals and timeline before quoting anything, so you know exactly what you're getting.

LocationBoca Raton, Florida
CoverageSouth Florida + remote nationwide
Status Now accepting clients